VENUES

THE STAR ONLINE

« Merry Christmas, from the Elders | Main | Review: The Swell Season »

November 30, 2009

Comments

Gulliver Foyle,  Jr.

You know, from reading that perfectly fair and accurate review, you would think that no one had a good time and it was a decent night of 90s rock and roll from a singer you couldn't understand and a band that was competent but bland.
The fact of the matter is that a tight group, led by a charismatic and totally beyond description female, had the crowd in the palm of her hand.
Did you see the crowd in the upper balcony?
I have had the pleasure of seeing some charismatic, even legendary front men (Bono, Liam O'Maonlai, Bruce Springsteen, Shane MacGowan) the last three months, but Dolores O'Riordan's performance matched or topped them all.
You think that maybe some critics feel a need to bring people down, as if thinking it couldn't really have been that good, could it?
Makes me think of Alexander Pope's line, what was it?

Delilah Brock

I was there and it was great. I don't know what the critic was drinking. The Dolores and band were fey (in the sense it was otherwordly). Those who can't perform are only left to criticize.

joeboo

You do realize that your opinion of a performance is probably biased to a certian degree if you are a fan of a band, as opposed to being a professional journalist who may or may not care anything about the band on a personal level?

The review was pretty positive from what I can tell. The only gripes were about the production, not the performance.

I can't imagine being able to objectively critique performances of bands, artists, or even genres that I don't like personally. It would be rough.

Discount Online Medical Marijuana

yer freekin lucky the reviewer even went to you lil show, he skips a lot of real concerts these days.

DiggityDawg

Wow - if you thought THAT was a negative review...

Simma down, Cranberries nerds.

Penny

I'm sure it was great. Would have loved to have been there...

Jerry Moore

I was there and I was blown away. After going back to their music over the last year I can only say the live performance enhances every song. Seeing Dolores in person perform and hearing the songs live, changed from in studio, made for a performance of a lifetime. I agree, at times the volume for the hall caused a lack of pure clarity but that plus it was live right in front of you all added together to make it more intense. She is a charismatic showman that I feel lucky to have been able to see from the 24th row. I was dancing all night.

DB

I do agree with the comment on the sound mix, It was my only complaint of the night, Good songs, good vocals, tight band, poor sound especially from the 3rd row in the balcony. Also the warm up Griffen House was a nice way to start the evening

actung Daughtery

Deutschland, Deutschland über alles,
Über alles in der Welt,
Wenn es stets zu Schutz und Trutze
Brüderlich zusammenhält.

Free WoW Time Cards

never heard of this band... :|

jerry

YouTube "live in Paris"... Promises rocks

Cranb

Hey, Free WoW Time Cards: When were you born? 2001? I can´t believe anybody who was interested in music in the 90s missed the Cranberries!

Maroussia

It will be great to watch The Cranberries, i have bought tickets from
http://ticketfront.com/event/The_Cranberries-tickets looking forward to it.

viagra online

I have an allergy to quinine. It was discovered by accident when I
was a toddler. I was given tonic water and reacted with a rash. My
skin has always been sensitive and reactive to certain foods. It
wasn't until recently that I read about quinine-like substances in
certain fruits, such as grapefruit. My question is, what other foods
have compounds with a similar chemical structure to quinine? Thanks
kindly for your help.

The comments to this entry are closed.

TIM FINN @ TWITTER


BUY TICKETS

.

  • .

MORE DANCING ABOUT ARCHITECTURE

  • All Music Guide
    Looking for that one song by that one band? Find it here.
  • Alternative Press
    The magazine's online edition.
  • Arthur
    "People with good taste, people who break ground, people who have a sense of passion, humor and righteousness for what they're covering."
  • Aversion.com
    A site for rock, punk and indie fans. Call it the new Pitchfork (but not as stuffy).
  • Dusted Magazine
    Brooklyn-based music mag's site is updated daily.
  • Harp
    The alt/Americana mag's site.
  • Magnet
    The online version of "the bi-monthly, internationally distributed, glossy music magazine that gives well-deserved attention to musicians largely ignored by mainstream publications."
  • Metacritic
    Lots and lots of critics praise and bitch about music (and movies, DVDs, games, books and TV).
  • Mojo
    More music from the U.K., with "Mojo Radio."
  • Paste
    "The premier magazine for people who still enjoy discovering new music, prize substance and songcraft over fads and manufactured attitude, and appreciate quality music in whatever genre it might inhabit."
  • Pitchfork
  • Play Louder
    News, reviews and MP3s.
  • PopMatters
    An international magazine of cultural criticism.
  • Q
    "The World's Greatest Music Magazine Online."
  • Stylus Magazine
    A daily web magazine that specializes in music.
  • The Fader
    The site for the hip hop mag.
  • The Middle Coast
    A music lover and blogger in Chicago blogs about music in Chicago (and elsewhere).
  • The Rest Is Noise
    Articles, a blog, and a book-in-progress by the music critic of The New Yorker.
  • The Word
    Word magazine notes on its About Us page that it is "for people too old for the NME and too hip for Q".
  • Trouser Press
    "The Bible" of alternative rock since 1983.
  • Uncut
    Music and movie mag from the U.K.
  • You Ain't No Picasso

GIVE A LISTEN

Blog powered by TypePad

LOOK HERE

  • Search
    Google

    WWW
    backtorockville.typepad.com