Back to Rockville: Review: Carrie Underwood

VENUES

Review: Carrie Underwood

Photos by Susan Pfannmuller/Special to The Star

Among the trove of trophies and awards she has collected over the past fiver years, Carrie Underwood has two "entertainer of the year" awards from the Academy of Country Music. Saturday night, before a full house at the Sprint Center, she showed why.

Since she won the "American Idol" crown five years ago, Underwood has evolved with light-speed into one of the biggest stars in modern country. She has done it with a combination of good looks, a charming and self-effacing personality and a voice that has blossomed -- exploded, actually -- into one of those voices, the kinds that can make an arena feel like a corner bar.

Saturday night she treated her 15,000 or so fans to an evening of hits and songs from her three studio albums; to an array of wardrobe changes; to several on-stage sets, including a swing to a cover of John Denver's "Take Me Home, Country Roads" delivered from the bed of a royal-blue pickup truck that road a rail high above the crowd and to just enough personal anecdotes and scrapbook photos (from her childhood to her wedding day) to spread a little homespun cheer.

The show lasted about 15 minutes short of two hours, comprised and included a couple of explosive moments. One of those was the woman-spurned anthem "Before He Cheats," one of the closers and the one song that prompted a loud, sustained sing-along. The other was "Jesus Take the Wheel," Underwood's first No. 1 single. She turned that song of inspiration into an evangelical moment when she appended it with part of the hymn "How Great Thou Art." Among the several impressive vocal moments of the show, this one was the most spectacular. She finished it with the kind of volume and sky-scraping notes that recalled Whitney Houston's National Anthem at the Super Bowl almost 20 years ago. It inspired lots of fans to look heavenward and waive both arms and prompted one of the loudest and longest cheers of the night. It was one moment when people looked genuinely moved and not just entertained.

The rest of the show illustrated how Underwood became the chart-busting star she is. She has three multi-platinum albums and 10 No. 1 singles because she records songs that are as highly crafted as they are generic and formulaic. Some sound like spin-offs of other songs, including her own but also the songs of other singer/songwriters. The bluesy anthem "Undo It," for example, is a remodeled version of Lucinda Williams' "Joy."

The effect of all that similarity and formula: She can raise the roof with her voice, but her songs don't move much furniture. The vibe in the room only broke percolation one or two times; otherwise there was lots of watching followed by cheers and hearty applause after each song. The last time she was in town, she delivered an infernal cover of Guns N' Roses' "Paradise City." This night could have used a moment like that.

Nearly all of those songs take full advantage of that voice, which, like a high-performancee engine, doesn't like hanging around in low gear. So she came out of the gate in high-decibel mode with two anthems built to fill arenas: "Cowboy Casanova" and "Quitter," both of which showcased an agile, leviathan voice that belies her petite stature and pleasant personae (like Martina McBride). Even when she sings a ballad, like "Wasted," it tends to erupt into something loud and dramatic.

The crowd did light up for "What Can I Say," which included openers Sons of Sylvia; for "I Told You So," a duet with a video of Randy Travis; and for two of her biggest hits, "Last Name" and "Before He Cheats."

She ended with "Songs Like This," a track from "Play On," her latest record. She dropped in a sample of Beyonce's "Single Ladies." A few years ago, that would come off as a moment of homage to someone Underwood obviously looks up to. But these days, she has a right to consider Beyonce one of her peers.

Billy Currington: He was the second of two openers, following the Sons of Sylvia, but he seems on the verge of becoming a big-venue headliner. Currington can do the beer-drinking, truck-driving honky-tonk thing as well as anyone in country music, but he can also kill a country-politan ballad, like "Must Be Doing Something Right," which was on the setlist. So were "That's How Country Boys Roll," "I Got a Feeling," "Pretty Good at Drinkin' Beer" and " Good Directions."

Carrie Underwood setlist: Cowboy Casanova; Quitter; Wasted; I Know You Won't; Some Hearts; Just a Dream; Temporary Home; Some Day When I Stop Loving You; All-American Girl; So Small; Take Me Home, Country Roads; This Time; Undo It; Jesus, Take the Wheel/How Great Thou Art; What Can I Say; Change; I Told You So; Mama's Song; Last Name; Songs Like This.

| Timothy FInn, The Star

Posted at 01:43 PM | Permalink

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

Posted by: |

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:

Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Post a comment

BUY TICKETS

Middle of the Map Fest
Featuring Fun, Neon Indian, Mates of State, Murder By Death, F***ed Up and Mission of Burma. April 5-7, Westport. $20 and $35.
Bassnectar
April 12, Midland. $29.50.
Experience Hendrix Tour
March 28, Midland. $40 to $89.50
The Elders Hoolie
March 17, Uptown Theater. $23 and $43.
Josh Turner
March 1, Uptown Theater. $30 and $50.
Jane's Addiction
March 16, Uptown Theater. $37.50 and $53.
Andrew Bird
March 23, Uptown Theater. $23 and $28.
George Strait and Martina McBride
Feb. 25, Sprint Center. $69.50 and $79.50.
Radiohead
March 11, Sprint Center. $48 and $58.
Mutemath
Feb. 16, Beaumont Club. $27.
In Flames, Trivium
Feb. 11, Beaumont Club. $23.50.

MORE DANCING ABOUT ARCHITECTURE

All Music Guide
Looking for that one song by that one band? Find it here.
Alternative Press
The magazine's online edition.
Arthur
"People with good taste, people who break ground, people who have a sense of passion, humor and righteousness for what they're covering."
Aversion.com
A site for rock, punk and indie fans. Call it the new Pitchfork (but not as stuffy).
Dusted Magazine
Brooklyn-based music mag's site is updated daily.
Harp
The alt/Americana mag's site.
Magnet
The online version of "the bi-monthly, internationally distributed, glossy music magazine that gives well-deserved attention to musicians largely ignored by mainstream publications."
Metacritic
Lots and lots of critics praise and bitch about music (and movies, DVDs, games, books and TV).
Mojo
More music from the U.K., with "Mojo Radio."
Paste
"The premier magazine for people who still enjoy discovering new music, prize substance and songcraft over fads and manufactured attitude, and appreciate quality music in whatever genre it might inhabit."
Pitchfork
Play Louder
News, reviews and MP3s.
PopMatters
An international magazine of cultural criticism.
Q
"The World's Greatest Music Magazine Online."
Stylus Magazine
A daily web magazine that specializes in music.
The Fader
The site for the hip hop mag.
The Middle Coast
A music lover and blogger in Chicago blogs about music in Chicago (and elsewhere).
The Rest Is Noise
Articles, a blog, and a book-in-progress by the music critic of The New Yorker.
The Word
Word magazine notes on its About Us page that it is "for people too old for the NME and too hip for Q".
Trouser Press
"The Bible" of alternative rock since 1983.
Uncut
Music and movie mag from the U.K.
You Ain't No Picasso

GIVE A LISTEN

Gorilla Vs. Bear
Recommended by B2R reader JS, who maintains bangpotential.com.
Audiobaba
Generate playlists and get recommendations from this "Personal Music Genie."
Coverville
Thrice-a-week podcasts of great cover songs.
Radio Paradise
Free online radio (though they'd appreciate your donations).
Pandora Internet Radio
Striving to create a "music genome."
The Live Music Archive
"A community committed to providing the highest quality live concerts in a lossless, downloadable format."
Turntable Lab
DJ equipment, production software and music and video.
Smithsonian Global Sound
Download and learn about traditional music from around the world.
Radio David Byrne
One of Entertainment Weekly's "Best Music Web Sites," Byrne says you can listen to "whatever I'm listening to."
Dusty Groove America
Buy and sell LPs.
Little Steven's Underground Garage
"The coolest songs in the world," as chosen by Uncle Silvio.
Mix Unit
Get your hip hop mixtapes here.
Soul Sides
"Music for rhythm addicts."
Music For Robots
Listening suggestions for, by and of music lovers.

Comments

Is she wearing a cape, Carrie Underwood is a superhero!

Posted by: Green | October 17, 2010 at 07:40 PM

We saw her in Nashville and thought she couldn't sing at all. I wonder where the disconnect is. Maybe the mix was bad or something....

Posted by: Clint | October 18, 2010 at 08:38 AM

@Clint
If you thought Carrie couldn't sing at all then the disconnect must be between your ears!

Posted by: TexasVet | October 18, 2010 at 10:08 AM

Carrie Underwood was at the MN state fair grandstand on 08/31. It was 12 days of shows during the MN state fair in St. Paul. I was at the fair on 08/27 to see Rush. This fair had several headliners for sure.

Posted by: Kurt | October 18, 2010 at 11:21 AM

Since your review indicated multiple wardrobe changes, would it have been asking too much for a pic of Ms.Underwood in a short skirt?

Posted by: pellboy | October 18, 2010 at 02:15 PM

Wow! Carrie Underwood is my favorite singer... really she sing a song amazingly. Thanks for sharing this great post here..... Your blog is really very interesting and informative. keep updating.

Posted by: generic viagra online | October 25, 2010 at 03:45 AM

Hmm, very sexy women for me!

Posted by: human anatomy | November 08, 2010 at 05:05 AM

Posted by: wow gold | July 22, 2011 at 02:06 AM

Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up!

Posted by: xanax | August 01, 2011 at 08:53 PM

I'm definitely tired of struggling to find relevant and intelligent comments on this topic.

Posted by: Cheap NBA Jerseys | August 02, 2011 at 09:21 PM

Since your review indicated multiple wardrobe changes, would it have been asking too much for a pic of Ms.Underwood in a short skirt?
Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.

Posted by: nfl cheap jerseys | August 03, 2011 at 01:38 AM

would it have been asking too much for a pic of Ms.Underwood in a short skirt?
Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.

Posted by: nfl jerseys | August 04, 2011 at 02:10 AM

He was the second of two openers, following the Sons of Sylvia, but he seems on the verge of becoming a big-venue headliner. Currington can do the beer-drinking, truck-driving honky-tonk thing as well as anyone in country music

Posted by: Dallas Cowboys jerseys | August 04, 2011 at 04:50 AM

Hi, thank you for sharing this great info. Was just browsing through the net in my office and happened upon your blog. It is really very well written and quit comprehensive in explaining with a very simple language.

Posted by: viagra online | August 05, 2011 at 09:23 AM

As for the Hawks, haven't heard anything either. Just the same rumors here and there that they're bringing back their "old" thirds, but nothing even close to concrete. Jerseys Rumors have been circulating that suggest the Blackhawks are looking to ditch their third jersey. At this point I don't have any hard sources to cite, but it sounds like team management doesn't really love this sweater (right) which began life in 2009 at the Winter Classic played at Wrigley Field in Chicago. I'm not certain whether the Blackhawks plan to revert to the previous all-black third NHL Jerseys, which first debuted in 1996 (and was later relaunched in Reebok Edge form in 2008 after taking a year off) — or go without an alternate uniform altogether. They could also try their hand an entirely new design, but I really wouldn't bet on that. Also unclear is the timetable for the current third jersey's demise. Have we already seen the last of it? Or will it get one last hurrah this season before it becomes part of Hawks history?

Posted by: nhl jerseys | August 15, 2011 at 04:01 AM

That's really a shame. I was hoping the Stars would get the chance to add a little more color. Now, if it does happen, it will likely have to wait at least until next season — maybe longer. Looking back, Dallas may have been the hardest hit by the transition to Reebok Edge in 2007. They went from having a beautiful and unique set of sweaters to some of the blandest in the league. And green — already in short supply around the NHL — disappeared almost entirely. For the record, the current set of uniforms will remain unchanged for 2011. I for one will be an upset Hawks fan that the current third will be retired. It completed arguably the finest uniform set in the league. I'm at least hoping it doesn't start a trend of a new alternate MLB jerseys every other year. As an original 6 team, the organization should strive to maintain a concrete identity without alternating too much between uniforms.

I like this post, enjoyed this one appreciate it for putting up.

Posted by: nhl jerseys cheap | August 30, 2011 at 10:01 PM

Buy online FAST increase or decrease in blood pressure Moduretic Find no prescriptions online runny nose, sinus problems, sneezing On-line.Buy pharmacy cheapest bromocriptine, ergot alkaloids, sulfites, other medicines, foods, dyes, or preservatives Moduretic LOWEST Antibiotics PRICE Overnight fedex shipping unusual or severe headache purchase online Norway Drug Shop +FREE Pills.Buy cheap online BEST PRICE Egypt cod saturday delivery difficulty passing urine Avalide medical side effects for United Kingdom Nextday shipping
buy Female viagra, buy Viagra soft, buy Cialis soft,

Posted by: sale benicar | August 31, 2011 at 03:33 AM

Wishing you the best of luck for all your blogging efforts.

Posted by: Moncler | September 01, 2011 at 08:18 PM

Well this was the best poat I have ever seen.

Posted by: Tampa bay Rays | September 06, 2011 at 02:20 AM

Sincerely thank you for your help
http://www.gevezechat.net

Posted by: sohbet | September 17, 2011 at 12:32 PM

Hi there, nice information provided. thanks for that. keep posting of blogs in the future. thanks once again..

Posted by: kamagra | September 20, 2011 at 06:00 AM

This topic is more informative. I use to have issues with my back and consequently I started a website to assist individuals using the same problems. Back problems can be extremely painful and some thing you should take serious.

Posted by: miami liposuction | September 26, 2011 at 12:43 PM

I started a website to assist individuals using the same problems. Back problems can be extremely painful and some thing you should take serious.

Posted by: Cheap Moncler Jackets | October 04, 2011 at 07:40 AM

Nice article and good information provided here, this female singer have good talent and she is really like a rockstar. Every tracks i listened and loved too. Keep singing and keep posting here.

Posted by: Hire PHP Developers | October 07, 2011 at 12:15 AM

thanks for the post.
www.sencart.com

Posted by: sencart | October 07, 2011 at 12:54 AM

YES. I have introduced a lot of friends look at this article.

Posted by: True Religion Outlet | October 10, 2011 at 02:14 AM

Very, very nicely done!

Posted by: Belstaff Abbigliamento UOMO | November 06, 2011 at 08:14 AM

I am very much pleased with the contents you have mentioned. I wanted to thank you for this great article. I enjoyed every little bit part of it and I will be waiting for the new updates.

projo

Posted by: projo | December 14, 2011 at 11:52 PM

keep posting of blogs in the future. thanks once again..

Posted by: gazeteler | December 15, 2011 at 07:08 PM

http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-walmart plavix walmart
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-resistance plavix resistance
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-ttp plavix ttp
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-usa plavix usa
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-problems plavix problems

Posted by: llnfapumoa | December 21, 2011 at 06:09 AM

http://www.mynetchat.com

Posted by: mynet chat | January 09, 2012 at 02:47 PM

ebnrmcbdlupspdlwjmmf, Free recipes, RaLQMyU, [url=http://recipesquestions.com/]Paula dean recipes[/url], HCkoOXL, http://recipesquestions.com/ Hamburger recipes, NwEoNEb, Webcam video capture 1 9, LCjTURj, [url=http://123webcam.org/]Webcam tube[/url], PHCFDId, http://123webcam.org/ Webcam teens, lOBLLbH, Heather silk password rapidshare or megaupload, HPoYepW, [url=http://megaupload-access.com/]Hancho girigiri megaupload[/url], bIawLbn, http://megaupload-access.com/ Your highness megaupload, IrRcCEy, How much finasteride for hairloss, ackcimn, [url=http://www.flannerys.net/about.html]Flomax snd finasteride[/url], NjMydiP, http://www.flannerys.net/about.html Cancer finasteride prostate, rMlUGdG, Buy meridia, QRUeAJz, [url=http://meridiaadvice.net/]Lslane@meridia.org[/url], jRKLNMV, http://meridiaadvice.net/ Gkious@meridia.org, aEPZzHh, Term life insurance quotes, AgPjnhT, [url=http://eformkit.com/]Cheap life insurance quotes in london[/url], MORrHuZ, http://eformkit.com/ Life Insurance Quotes, bmqcREA.

Posted by: Mega Upload | January 26, 2012 at 03:07 AM

xkgdtcbdlupspdlwjmmf, Tava Tea, yTHcMrq, [url=http://tavatea4u.com/]Tava Tea[/url], tgzStYZ, http://tavatea4u.com/ Tava Tea, IsPQjbP, Cheap ambien, cDkYMIx, [url=http://alltolled.com/mitchsmyths.htm]Ambien online buy[/url], aDDIpkW, http://alltolled.com/mitchsmyths.htm Ambien generic name, wKLOajS, Intivar, SvtuMoV, [url=http://intivartoday.net/]Intivar[/url], nEWtNOM, http://intivartoday.net/ Intivar, ZrCBXAB, colon hydrotherapy, ADLdXyb, [url=http://healthydiettrends.com/maxcleanse-free-trial-review]Max Cleanse[/url], afASRxv, http://healthydiettrends.com/maxcleanse-free-trial-review colon cancer, kRtKBFM, Order ambien no prescription, tBqTCDS, [url=http://www.45secondprospecting.com/ambien.html]Ambien website[/url], EtQVGME, http://www.45secondprospecting.com/ambien.html Order ambien from canada, xUcxqBU, bella labs, WBCxhpk, [url=http://getbellalabs.com/]bella labs[/url], ENfJabZ, http://getbellalabs.com/ Bella labs, OWxVNhi.

Posted by: Intivar | January 26, 2012 at 03:10 AM

mhctfcbdlupspdlwjmmf, Buy-best-k ultram -dgiqbl, VKIiryk, [url=http://www.carriagebandb.com/house.html]Buy Ultram[/url], tdXaAIF, http://www.carriagebandb.com/house.html Ultram use, spmxRnS.

Posted by: Ultram | January 26, 2012 at 03:15 AM

aglsrcbdlupspdlwjmmf, Winamp media files converter, ucHMNFx, [url=http://winampquestions.org/]Winamp[/url], dqerjjG, http://winampquestions.org/ Winamp ipod, WAKQOxm, Pain medications and zoloft interactions, SLcDatJ, [url=http://www.zoloftpharm.com/]Zoloft[/url], EMLjcOw, http://www.zoloftpharm.com/ Zoloft, rxHUQaH, Cialis vs viagra, BKEdsqi, [url=http://surplusviagra.com/]Female viagra[/url], nSCxlNj, http://surplusviagra.com/ Buy viagra now, bfpmXyE, Unmetered traffic dedicated servers with paypal, mDRFgrd, [url=http://dedicatedserversfaq.com/]Steam code for dedicated servers[/url], uLEzydC, http://dedicatedserversfaq.com/ Dedicated Servers, ZbYBxxR, Irs, johVffp, [url=http://irsfaq.net/]Irs form w9[/url], BdVVbVS, http://irsfaq.net/ Irs refund status, ldoeOdt, Game Cracks, aDSakus, [url=http://gamecracksanswers.info/]Game cracks[/url], oZRRQAk, http://gamecracksanswers.info/ Free downloads of audio game cracks?, cLztaAR.

Posted by: Dedicated servers antwerpen | January 26, 2012 at 03:21 AM

nohtgcbdlupspdlwjmmf, Order priligy online, jusDDyV, [url=http://www.btxformfactor.com/priligy.html]Buy priligy[/url], sMkmNzd, http://www.btxformfactor.com/priligy.html Priligy 30 mg, PaTtVSa.

Posted by: Priligy buy | January 26, 2012 at 03:23 AM

tguyocbdlupspdlwjmmf, Tribulus and dhea stacked with ephedrine hcl and caffeine, kJrTVbP, [url=http://www.poorboysupplements.com/]Fat Burners[/url], MHMXsXJ, http://www.poorboysupplements.com/ Fat Burners, DQnTaCI, Interesting superbowl bets, jcYHZsN, [url=http://www.superbowlbets.org/]Superbowl Bets[/url], ucpVJiZ, http://www.superbowlbets.org/ Superbowl 45 prop bets, GUFvrUS, Web site design vancouver, sIFEOBh, [url=http://prdesign.ca/]Web design in vancouver[/url], dfIxQyk, http://prdesign.ca/ Small business web design vancouver, wpywCgs, Gas fireplaces denver, WUnOXEu, [url=http://www.bestgasfireplaces.org/]Gas Fireplaces[/url], IgeHKSl, http://www.bestgasfireplaces.org/ Vented gas fireplaces, tRdzlIU, Minecraft Servers, lrgfVnW, [url=http://minecraftsandbox.com/]Minecraft Servers[/url], CSCMokc, http://minecraftsandbox.com/ Minecraft Servers, onoLTNC, Reneuve supplement reviews, wqqUGhK, [url=http://www.supplementnews.org/]Ravage supplement reviews side effects[/url], wAGgdDL, http://www.supplementnews.org/ Amino Acid Reviews, XQrOLTs.

Posted by: Supplement Reviews | January 27, 2012 at 05:06 PM

cgvzycbdlupspdlwjmmf, http://www.gyrzzvuszi.com zvkqraqctd

Posted by: atrwyuwcmc | January 28, 2012 at 02:19 AM

bsovycbdlupspdlwjmmf, Regrow Hair, LdvQzyj, [url=http://www.regrow.info/]Hair Regrowth Products[/url], Utawvig, http://www.regrow.info/ Hair Regrowth Products, aealQJU, Dog Snuggie, dvkwxZr, [url=http://ly2fromwf.com/]Dog Snuggie[/url], OebUNwy, http://ly2fromwf.com/ Dog Snuggie, qjoekZA, Vitamin D, aqyYxhy, [url=http://tyhealth.com/10-reasons-why-you-need-vitamin-d]Vitamin d 50 000 unit cap pliva[/url], sPhyhUv, http://tyhealth.com/10-reasons-why-you-need-vitamin-d Zinc magnesium calcium vitamin d synergy, DMaIahn, Dark Eye Circle Cream, BWhJwCq, [url=http://www.vivexin.com/]Dark Eye Circle Cream[/url], zoahRHE, http://www.vivexin.com/ Dark circle eye cream, ogoptjo, Superbowl 45 prop bets, lPwiBeo, [url=http://www.superbowlbets.org/]Superbowl Bets[/url], JPGmyrP, http://www.superbowlbets.org/ Superbowl Bets, tIZGUWD, Angry birds game online, jEbNTsD, [url=http://angrybirdshub.com/]Angry birds chrome angry birds chrome online play angry[/url], yLjSzaY, http://angrybirdshub.com/ Play angry birds online for free, lNoXrUV.